• by Dr. María “Cuca” Robledo Montecel • IDRA Newsletter • June – July 2010 • Dr. María “Cuca” Robledo Montecel, Ph.D.

Editor’s note: The original statement released by IDRA before adoption of these measures in Texas in 2009 is available online at http://www.idra.org/Press_Room/Recent_Statements/. For specific provisions of these measures, see IDRA’s Newsletter Plus. 

At no point in history has Texas had a pipeline that moves all or even most students from quality early childhood education to college graduation and beyond. Today, our public schools are losing tens of thousands of students every year. And we only have a 5 percent higher education participation rate. That rate is a mere 3.7 percent for Hispanic students.

This affects everyone. In order to survive and thrive, Texans must be educated. Not just a few. All Texans.

But rather than embracing the challenge, some state leaders seem intent on lowering expectations. Unfortunately the new “accountability” plans that were adopted for Texas do not necessarily result in – as claimed by proponents – the creation of schools that educate all students to a true level of college readiness. In fact, these measures most likely will have a devastating effect on our state. Specifically, “accountability” policies are counterproductive when they:

  • Bring back tracking of students into college and work (career/technical) tracks
  • Lower standards for some students by decreasing performance standards required for graduation
  • Give up on the idea that all students should be prepared for college by allowing schools to support only some students for college
  • Provide no safeguards preventing over-referral of minority students into non-college tracks
  • Substitute one set of high-stakes assessments with other high-stakes measures
  • Lower performance standards for schools and students by requiring demonstrated achievement in just two content areas
  • Weaken content in math and science courses by allowing substitution of career and technical education “equivalent” courses in all content areas
  • Do little to address the over-testing of students and over-reliance on test scores
  • Remove whatever transparency exists in the state’s accountability system by hopelessly complicating the process used to rate school and district performance
  • Fail to provide any substantive funding to support the many changes required

In short, counterproductive accountability policies do nothing to ensure that the state will produce the highly educated workforce needed to be competitive in a global economy.

Texas cannot afford to move backwards. We cannot lower the bar and then claim to have increased the success rate, using smoke and mirrors to create another “Texas miracle.” While disguised as a move to address all the ills of prior reform efforts – including provisions in the increasingly unpopular NCLB – some parts of the changes represent a giant step backward for Texas education. Years of work will be needed to clean up the newly created quagmire. A vital Texas must have educational parity for all Texans and not parcel out one set of opportunities for some and minimal expectations for others. Our current challenge of getting more of our schools and students to perform at high levels should not be met with a headlong effort to make it easier for everyone to look good. It is not time to run and hide. It is time to stand firm and defend what we know is good for all students.

Dr. María “Cuca” Robledo Montecel, is IDRA President and CEO. Comments and questions may be directed to IDRA via e-mail at feedback@idra.org.

[©2010, IDRA. This article originally appeared in the June-July 2010 IDRA Newsletter by the Intercultural Development Research Association. Permission to reproduce this article is granted provided the article is reprinted in its entirety and proper credit is given to IDRA and the author.]