The Class of 2016 saw Graduation Rates of 62% in Charter Schools compared to 90% in Traditional Public Schools
News Release: San Antonio (December 13, 2017) – Texas students in charter schools are not necessarily faring better than their peers in traditional public schools. With significantly lower graduation rates and lower accountability ratings reported by the Texas Education Agency, the state’s planned expansion of charter schools is troubling. In an additional analysis to IDRA’s annual attrition study released in October, IDRA examined the annual dropout and longitudinal graduation rates in Texas charter schools from 2009 to 2016.
Key findings show:
- The Class of 2016 saw graduation rates of 62 percent in charter schools compared to 90 percent in traditional public schools.
- While some charter schools serve some of the students in highest need, analysis of TEA data for 2016-17 statewide reveals that there is very little difference in the percentage of students served who are considered at risk of dropping out: 50 percent in traditional schools compared to 52 percent in charter schools.
- Nearly one out of every five charter campuses (22.9 percent) failed to achieve “met standard” or the lower “alternative standard,” compared to about one of every 25 traditional public schools.
- Texas public schools serve 5.4 million students, while charter schools serve only 273,000. State funding for charter schools increased at a much faster rate than for public schools in the last decade, with an 8 percent increase for traditional schools compared to a 236 percent increase for charters.
“Texas needs to let go of the claim that charter schools can ‘rescue’ students from their so-called failing neighborhood public schools. As our communities predicted, the data show otherwise. Our families and communities don’t need ‘rescuing’ by lottery. They demand strong neighborhood public schools,” said Dr. María “Cuca” Robledo Montecel, IDRA president and CEO.
“The state of Texas is required to provide an excellent education for all students. Rather than funneling tax money to private interests or to charter school operators that are not accountable to the public, our state must shore up neighborhood public schools where all students graduate from high school prepared for college or the world of work, no matter what the color of their skin, the language they speak, or where they happen to be born,” she continued.
With a three-year grant of $59,164,996 from the U.S. Department of Education, the State of Texas is planning the expansion of 115 new charter schools.
IDRA’s Quality School Action Framework™ guides communities and schools in identifying weak areas and strengthening public schools’ capacities to graduate and prepare all students for success. IDRA’s book, Courage to Connect: A Quality Schools Action Framework shows how communities and schools can work together to be successful with all of their students.
# # #
IDRA Attrition Study & Resources
Charter School Article: Annual Dropout and Longitudinal Graduation Rates in Texas Charter Schools, 2009-2016
Infographic: Pomp and Poor Circumstances – Texas charter schools miss the graduation and accountability mark according to TEA reports
News Release: Texas High School Attrition Reaches All-Time Low of 29% for Hispanic Students – 32nd Annual Texas Public School Attrition Study Released by IDRA
2017 Full Study (PDF) – Texas Public School Attrition Study, 2016-17
Look Up Your County – See attrition rates and numbers over the last eight years
County List – See which counties had attrition rates go up or down
Infographic: Texas public schools are losing one out of four students
eBook on types of dropout data
College Bound and Determined – A report profiling what happens when a school district raises expectations for students instead of lowering them
Checklist Tool – Quality School Holding Power Checklist