Education Policy

Stop Vouchers

Girl in front of a chalk boardPublic funds should remain in public schools, with oversight from local communities.

Federal and state leaders are pushing harder than ever to divert public money to private schools.

Get resources here to help Texas say no to vouchers!

New Data Map: The Big Cost of Proposed Voucher Legislation – IDRA Map and Dashboard by State Senate Districts, State House Districts, Traditional Public School Districts, and Charter School Districts

Op-Ed: The ‘Texas Three-Step’: Defund, Demonize, and Privatize Public Schools – Vouchers become subsidies for families who had already decided to pay for private school, at the expense of public schools that must serve all students, by Chloe Latham Sikes, Ph.D., in the Texas Observer, February 4, 2025

Podcast & Video: The Truth About Private School Vouchers – Classnotes Podcast 248

Infographic: 5 Reasons Private School Vouchers Would Hurt Students

Map: Distance to Private Schools by Texas Senate and House Districts

Map: Dispersed Private Schools by Georgia Senate and House Districts

eBook: School Dollars Diverted in 2023 A Scan of Private School Voucher Legislation in the U.S. South, by Terrence Wilson, J.D.

Video Gallery: See videos of testimony and other advocacy activities by IDRA and others against vouchers in Texas.


The best way to strengthen public schools is to strengthen public schools.

Diverting public money for private schools and subsidies for the rich takes money away from our communities resulting in higher taxes for homeowners and businesses. More importantly, private school vouchers, education savings accounts (ESAs), charter schools and related schemes further segregate students and do not result in improved learning.

Investing in our neighborhood public schools is investing in our community.

Policies that funnel much-needed resources to charter schools, private school vouchers, and other similar programs hurt traditional public schools and the students and families they serve.  

Traditional public schools receive public funds, are operated by publicly-elected school boards, and should be held accountable by the communities, families and students they serve. Public governance, engagement and accountability are critical parts of ensuring strong schools for all students. Private schools by design are selective and exclusive, not accountable to elected bodies, and allowed to operate without regard to rules and regulations applicable to public schools, including requirements related to special education and civil rights.

IDRA collaborates with students, families, and other advocacy organizations to protect and improve traditional public schools. Our research and advocacy aim to challenge the narratives that lead to bad policies and practices that harm public school students. 


Resources on Keeping the Public in Public Education

Changing Policy

2025

Voucher Systems are Unfair and Unconstitutional – IDRA Invited Testimony against HB 3, submitted by Paige Duggins-Clay, J.D, to the Texas House Committee on Public Education, March 11, 2025

Students Should Receive Language Protections and Programs in Any State-Funded Education System – IDRA Testimony Against HB 3, Submitted by Chloe Latham Sikes, Ph.D., to the Texas House Committee on Public Education, March 11, 2025

Education Saving Accounts Harm Efforts to Fully Fund Public Schools – TLEEC Testimony Against House Bill 3, submitted by Kaci Wright to the Texas House Public Education Committee, March 11, 2025

Education Savings Accounts are Inefficient and Ineffective for General Diffusion of Knowledge, Student Achievement and School Investments – IDRA Testimony against SB 2, Submitted by Chloe Latham Sikes, Ph.D., to the Texas Senate Committee on Education K-16, January 28, 2025

Don’t Prioritize Politics and Profits Over the Families Policymakers Should Be Representing – Testimony Against Senate Bill 2, Presented by Lizdelia Piñón, IDRA Education Associate, to the Texas Senate Committee on Education (PK-16), January 28, 2025 (Plus testimony by Sixth Grader, Felicita Piñón)

Education Saving Accounts Harm Texas Students’ Access to an Equitable Education – TLEEC Testimony Against Senate Bill 2, submitted by Kaci Wright to the Texas Senate Committee on K-16 Education, January 28, 2025

2024

Voucher Bill Harms Georgia’s Public School Students – Statement by IDRA and GYJC Opposing Senate Bill 233, March 20, 2024

Supporting Public Schools is the Best Way to Create Boundless Opportunities for Students – IDRA Testimony submitted to the House Education Subcommittee on Policy Subcommittee in opposition to House Bill 1221, February 20, 2024

Private School Vouchers Undermine Texas Students’ Ability to Access Equitable Educational Opportunities – TLEEC Testimony on Educational Opportunities in Texas, submitted by Chloe Latham Sikes, Ph.D., to the Texas House Committee on Public Education, August 12, 2024

Voucher Bill Harms Georgia’s Public School Students – Statement by IDRA and GYJC Opposing Senate Bill 233, March 20, 2024

See more about IDRA’s work in Georgia against vouchers.

• See our policy work in previous years


Acting on Research and Data 

Policy Brief: Keep Public Funds in Texas Public Schools – Reject Harmful Private School Voucher Programs  Invest In Public Education, Public Funds Public Schools, May 2023

Fact Sheet: The True Costs of Private School Voucher Programs, Public Funds Public Schools, September 2023

Report: The Fiscal Consequences of Private School Vouchers, Southern Poverty Law Center & Education Law Center, 2023

The State of Funding Equity Data Tool, The Education Trust, 2023

Issue Brief: How Texas Schools are Funded – And Why that Matters to Collective Success, by Chloe Latham Sikes, Ph.D

Analysis: Cutting Public School Relief Funds to Subsidize Private Schools

Study: Texas Charter School System Suffers Low Graduation Rates

InfographicCharter School Study – Pomp and Poor Circumstances

Policy Brief: Why More Charter Schools and School Vouchers Are Not Needed in Texas


Engaging Communities

Keep Public Funds in Texas Public Schools – Reject Harmful Private School Voucher Programs, Invest in Public Education, Public Funds Public Schools, May 2023

Say No to Vouchers, Yes to Public Education! ¡Los Vales No Valen! (English-Spanish)

The Voucher Deception

Public Money for Public Schooling – Training Kit

Texas: Letter to Texas Education Commissioner re 2020 Charter Amendments 

Texas: Joint Letter to TEA Regarding Implementation of the Common Charter Application and Charter Waiting List

Texas: Joint Statement: Increase the Transparency and Efficiency of Charter Schools in Texas

Georgia: Joint Letter: Opposition to Georgia’s Proposed Expansion of School Vouchers 


Communicating Effectively 

News Story: Both sides of the school voucher debate are invoking the Civil Rights Movement. Who is right? by Edward McKinley, Houston Chronicle, March 20, 2025

Infographic: 5 Reasons Private School Vouchers Would Hurt Students

Podcast: Happy Hour 130: Why School Vouchers Are Bad For Texas, And How to Fight Back, Progress Texas

Article: School Segregation through Vouchers – What Policymakers Can Learn from a History of State Efforts to Use Vouchers to Avoid Integration, by Paige Duggins-Clay, J.D., IDRA Knowledge is Power, February 7, 2023

Article: Lawmakers Refuse to Adopt School Vouchers, For Now, by Diana Long, IDRA Newsletter, June-July 2023

School Vouchers 101, Raise Your Hand Texas

Infographic: Texas Schools Need Funds to Serve Students 

Infographic: Texas State Divestment of Education

Statement: Vouchers: Unwise, Unworkable & Unfair

Bill targets Texas charter school admissions, Austin American-Statesman, March 21, 2019

Sistema escolar chárter con tasas bajas de graduación. Agencia de Educación de Texas, Edelia Hernández, El Mañana, January 11, 2018


For historical resources, see IDRA’s pre-2020 stop privatization site.

Share